Previous | Table of Contents | Next
Time was running out, and the closer everyone reached the shore, the closer I came to being exposed. No one’s eye was on me, so I took the initiative. I ducked my head under the water and then swam like my life depended on it. I didn’t come up for a breath until I was back on the side of the nudist beach. I had to find my swim trunks. I quickly started swimming toward the area we had been in when Donna found us out.
I already decided. Once I found my suit, I’d leave the nudist exit, get dressed, and then take the other path. I’d make something up about going to the bathroom or something. If they saw me returning from the nude beach, I could never explain myself, after all. Yet, I couldn’t see them floating anywhere. I was just about to consider stealing a pair from one of the naked couples on the beach when a voice spoke out.
“Looking for these.”
I turned to see Margot swimming, and in her hands was my swimsuit. My eyes widened and then narrowed suspiciously.
“Margot… give me the swimsuit.”
“Okay…” She tossed it to me.
I caught it with relief, but when I unfolded them, I let out a cry. That’s because it wasn’t my swimsuit. I recognized them as the ones she had been wearing.
“Wh-what are you doing?”
“I didn’t want you to feel left out.” She smirked, the expression never touching her eyes.
“Margot, this isn’t a game. I know how you like to play, but last time went too far…”
Her eyes flashed. “I know this isn’t a game. It seems you’re still trying to misinterpret things at your convenience, so I’ll make it clear. I love you.”
“Margot…” I looked away from her piercing eyes. “I love you too. You’re my little aunt. I love you as family.”
“Tch… since you wish to be stubborn…” She held up my real suit. “If you want this back, you’ll have to fuck me.”
I winced. We had already had sex once, I supposed one more time wouldn’t change anything.
“Fine, when we get back…”
“No, right now, on the beach. I want you to declare your love for me while cumming inside me. I want everyone to see you proclaim your love for me.”
“What?” I cried out. “I-I can’t…”
This was far too public. Having sex on the beach was against the rules, even if it was a nude beach. Plus, all those naked perverts would be watching us.
“I keep track of my menstrual cycle. I’m in my fertile window right now. I’m probably pregnant, but I want to make sure we have a baby. Then you can’t deny our love.”
“P-pregnant!” That’s when I remembered something. “No, you said go ahead… you’re on birth control.”
“I’m not,” she assured. “If you convince me that you love me as more than just family, I’ll take a plan B. Otherwise, congratulations, you’re a daddy.”
I tried to see if she was joking. She always liked to push things too far. However, I didn’t see any humor on her face. I believed she didn’t take birth control. At this point, if she didn’t take a day-after pill, she really would be pregnant! If I didn’t fuck her one more time and put on a good performance, then I didn’t know what Margot was capable of.
I looked around, seeing how many people were around. With a defeated look, I gave her a nod. She smiled and took my hand. I guided her back to the shore, but I aimed for an area more secluded than most of the beach. There was a rock jutting out of the sand that blocked the view from all sides. This would keep us from being immediately seen. As we got behind the rock, she pushed me down to my knees and tossed my swimsuit in the sand. I ended up seeing her entire naked body, which I had been diverting my eyes from earlier.
I was a bit stunned, but the sight of her breasts and her seductive smile snapped me back into reality. I reached out, taking her breasts into my hands. I groped and massaged her small tits. They were firm, and I felt her nipples hardening. I squeezed her soft mounds, and she moaned and pressed her body against me.
While I felt her up, she was busy too. She took my dick and stroked it. It quickly became hard. I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t turned on by my little aunt. The dark monster inside me started to immediately take control. I told myself that it was because I didn’t want her pregnant, but a small part of me was excited by the idea of her being pregnant. I imagined her with a baby bump and milk-producing tits, and it made me excited. I leaned down and began sucking on her breasts. My tongue swirled around her nipples, and I gently nibbled on them. While I was enjoying her soft chest, I could feel her rubbing her pussy against my shaft. She was grinding herself on me. She was getting off without even taking me inside her.
I pulled my head back, and she did the same. We were breathing heavily, and her cheeks were flushed. She was so beautiful. I reached down, guiding my tip toward her entrance.
Margot was a petite girl, unlike Carol. Her breasts were modest and she was only five feet tall, and very slim. Her body was a little curvy, but most of it was just muscle tone. She was the kind of girl you could fantasize about dominating. I could pick her up and fuck her standing, or push her down and have my way with her and she’d be helpless. Perhaps, that was why Margot had become so clever, to make up for her small stature. She’d always been a sneaky and mischievous girl, but the older she got the more cunning she became.
My cockhead pushed into her, and she bit her lip. The first few inches went in with no resistance. It was easier this time since I had already taken her virginity. I felt her insides squeeze down, and her legs shook. Her body trembled, and I could tell she was enjoying it. Her cute noises excited the dark part of me. My evil side took charge, and I pushed more of my thick cock into her. She squeaked and threw her head back.
“Nngh!”
She had her eyes shut tight and her face was completely red. She had a goofy grin plastered on her face. Her lips were trembling and drool was coming out of her mouth. The look on her face was a mixture of pain and pleasure. It was like her whole body was tingling.
As my dick slid into her, I could feel everything. This was my second time, and I had never used a condom. Would I even be able to when the time came? It was already too late to think about that. There was no way I could stop. The thought of impregnating her had been arousing, but at the same time, it also terrified me. I could get her pregnant, and that would destroy my relationship with Felicia. Not just Felicia, it would ruin my relationship with my entire family.
However, at the same time, another dark thought entered my head. A part of me wanted to get her pregnant, a part of me wanted to make Margot mine. Maybe, I could have both Felicia and Margot. I could live a normal life with my wife while visiting my little aunt and having my way with her on weekends. She could pretend it was some random guy’s baby, and my family would raise it. After all, both I and Margot were the results of one-night stands, so it’s not like my dad or hers had room to complain.
Stirred by these dark and shameful thoughts, I pushed Margot down onto the sand, getting on top of her. Her legs spread out and wrapped around my hips. Her arms coiled around my neck and her hands gripped the back of my head. We were locked together, staring into each other’s eyes. I could see a fire burning behind her emerald pupils.
“Evan… I love you,” she breathed.
“I love you too.” My dark lust was overtaking me, and it was affecting my words.
Margot’s expression was changing as she stared at me. “Y-you mean it, don’t you?”
“Yes.” At that moment, my dark desires were speaking for me.
“You want me to be your woman, not just family?”
“No, you’re family,” I said, but when she looked a little disappointed, I continued. “I’m going to make you the mother of my child!”
“Nnnghh!” She moaned and bit her lip as I began to pound her tight cunny.
I started to pump my hips. Margot’s arms and legs tightened, pulling me closer. She was so much smaller than me, but her strength was impressive. Her face was buried in the crook of my neck. I could hear her heavy breaths and moans. My cock was stretching her out. Her insides were quivering, and I could feel her squeezing me tight. She was dripping wet, and her juices were mixing with my precum. Our fluids were smearing against each other.
“Haaaah… ah! Evan!” She cried out.
I had one hand on the sand, while the other was groping her ass. Her pussy felt incredible. Her soft insides were wrapped around my thick cock. Every thrust in and out was driving me crazy. Her insides were hugging my shaft, and her body was trembling. It was like her insides were vibrating.
Her pussy was so hot and slick. Her juices were oozing out of her, making her insides nice and slippery. She was so warm, and her scent was intoxicating. It was a musky and erotic odor. It was a smell that I recognized. It was a primal aroma, and it filled my nostrils and filled my body with desires. My dick twitched as her body shook.
I had her pinned beneath me, and she was helpless to stop me. She didn’t try though. She had given me her body completely. I no longer blamed her for enticing and playing with me. I knew she wanted me. Perhaps, I had always known she wanted me. The truth was that I wanted her too. I couldn’t hold it back any longer. My hand reached up and grabbed her short blonde hair tightly.
“You’re my woman,” I grunted as my balls slapped against her.
“Yes!” She squealed. “I’m yours, forever!”
My hips were moving so fast, it felt like I was trying to break her. My little aunt was taking every inch, and it was turning me on. I had fucked her before, but it had been slow. I was inexperienced and was still trying to figure things out. Now, I was ravishing her. It was fast, wet, and hard. It was almost like I was fucking her for the first time, and it was exhilarating. The look of pure joy on her face made my dick throb.
“I love you!” I declared again, feeling my orgasm drawing near.
“Me too!” She shouted. “I love you too!”
Her insides were tightening around me, and I could tell she was going to cum. I kept pumping my hips. I could feel my balls churning. The hot and wet sensation was sending waves of pleasure up my spine. My cock was getting ready to blow.
“I’m gonna cum!” I grunted.
“Yes, do it!” She cried. “Do it inside!”
Her legs were clamped around me, and I couldn’t escape. I couldn’t hold it back anymore. I let out a cry, and I blew my load deep inside her. My dick pulsed and twitched as my seed flooded her womb. Her pussy tightened and she came with me.
“Ahhhhh! Evan!” She moaned loudly.
“Cumming!”
Our orgasms lasted for several seconds. It felt like the longest orgasm I had ever had. It made every other time pale.
“Ahhh… sooo much… it’s filling my womb…” her body shook as she climaxed, her pussy milking my cock. “You’re making me pregnant.”
I didn’t feel any horror. I felt excitement. Even though I came, my dark side didn’t seem to be receding. I still wanted Margot. I wanted Margot and Felicia. I wanted them both to be my women. I knew it was an awful thought, but I didn’t care. My dark desires were overcoming me.
When I had finished cumming, I pulled out. Cum started leaking out of her and running down her leg. Margot looked completely spent, lying there naked and breathing hard, a completely satisfied look on her face.
“Ahem.”
The pair of us looked up, and several couples were on top of the rocks, looking down on us. My body covered most of Margot’s naked body. So, they couldn’t see her. All they had seen was my naked ass as I pounded my little aunt. My eyes fell on the bouncer though. He was there too. We had made too much of a scene and were found out.
That’s how I ended up getting a lifetime ban from the nude beach. After a stern warning, we were ejected from the beach, thankfully with our swimsuits back on. I received a lot of dirty looks too. I had entered with one woman and left with another, so I supposed they were earned. Although it had only been a short time, I felt like my entire attitude had changed.
Margot didn’t seem to care about the looks at all. She was holding my arm and leaning against me affectionately. It felt really good.
“I’ll get the pill later,” she promised.
“Don’t.” I coughed when Margot looked up at me surprised. “I mean, if it happens, it happens.”
She gave me a mischievous look. “What are you saying?”
We had reached the split in the pathway.
I stopped, taking her arms in my hands. “Margot, I love you.”
Her body shook. “I’ve been wanting to hear those words for so long.”
I bit my lip. “I love Felicia too. She’s my fiancée, and I still plan to marry her.”
She stared up at me expressionlessly. “Okay…”
“I don’t plan to give you up though. I still want to fuck you. I don’t want any other man to touch you. I want you to have my baby.”
“Are you saying you want me and Felicia together?” She asked.
“I… I can’t tell Felicia about us.” As I said that, I knew I was complete trash, but I couldn’t stop. “The best you can be is my mistress. We’ll have to keep our relationship secret from everyone. Do you understand?”
“Cool.”
“I know… this is… eh?”
“I love you, Evan… unconditionally. I will never stop. I’ll take you any way I can have you,” she declared. “As for Felicia though, she’s a good girl. You should tell her the truth. She might be more willing than you think. Don’t be so selfish…”
“How can you say that? What girl would share her man with others? Asking you both to accept a relationship is selfis- Ow!” Margot bopped me on the head. “What was that for?”
“You can be dumb sometimes.” She laughed. “You think you’re the only one with feelings. You can’t ignore all the women who want you forever. That would be selfish. At some point, you need to realize you’re not meant for one woman… or even two.”
I frowned. “What is that supposed to mean.”
She giggled. “Nothing, you’ll figure it out on your own. When you do, I’ll still be there for you. I am… y-your woman.”
When she spoke those last words, she blushed.
“Evaaan! Evan!” I heard Felicia’s voice before I saw her running down the trail. “Oh, there you are?”
It was enough time to let go of Margot and turn away from her. That’s when my eyes landed on my fiancée. As she ran on the trail, her breasts bounced up and down. Although she wasn’t as large as Donna or Carol, her cute outfit pushed her boobs together and they were substantial enough to make it a breathtaking site.
I didn’t realize I was staring at her boobs until Felicia stopped in front of me. She let out a relieved sigh.
“You disappeared again. We were all worried.” As her eyes followed mine, she suddenly turned red, squirming in front of me.
“Sorry, I suddenly grew um… seasick and had to run off.”
“Oh.” Felicia looked up at me, biting her lip cutely.
“I changed my mind,” Margot said. “You have to choose one.”
“Eh?” I turned to her in shock. “Why?”
She pressed her fingers together looking guilty. “What’s so nice about cow udders anyway?”
“Hm?” Felicia thankfully didn’t understand the conversation.
We went back to the beach. No one seemed to be suspicious about Margot and my disappearance. Dad had more trouble getting the grill going than he thought, so the food was only just finished cooking as we arrived. The others figured we’d show up when we showed up and weren’t too worried. They accepted my explanation without issue.
I sat by Felicia and held her hand as we ate. My little aunt was the only one who could tell something had changed between us. She sat next to me and went the entire trip without teasing me any further. I found myself hoping she’d do more. I thought about groping her a few times, but I didn’t see a good chance. Things had begun to change, and there was no going back.
Overall, the trip went very well. The girls got to play around in the sand. I got to sit and have some chats with my dad and grandpa while we admired the beauties running around. This was the life.
“We’re pretty lucky guys,” Grandpa said, opening a bottle of beer and handing one to each of us.
“I think, my son is the one who is going to luck out the most,” Dad quipped, and then he and Grandpa laughed.
I gave them a confused look, but when they didn’t explain more, I took it to mean that Felicia was exceptionally beautiful. Well, Margot was beautiful too, and she was mine. That wasn’t to say Carol and Donna weren’t just as beautiful, but I couldn’t take them from my dad and grandpa. Even I wasn’t that bad.